Boot shopping can be overwhelming, but it doesn’t have to be.  No two feet are the same, so when it comes to browsing the boot market, I suggest an individualized approach to finding the right pair. With that in mind, there are a few qualities which apply to everyone when looking for the right boot.

1.) Size & Fit. Poorly fitted and uncomfortable boots can result in musculoskeletal related foot pain, skin complications such as irritation, blisters, or ulcers. Keep in mind that even if you’re feet have been properly measured, sizing differs among different manufacturers, brands, and even within the same brand.

2.) High quality material. Although more expensive, high-quality material is worth the investment for ideal foot comfort with boot durability, and longevity.

3.) Support. A boot with both arch and ankle support will provide your foot with the proper foundation which facilitates easy movement.

4.) Stability.  Boots should be designed to withstand snow, ice, and other dangerous conditions that inclement winter weather can bring along. A sole with a good grip, and a low, sturdy heel are best for maximum traction.

Best overall: The Bryson boot from Birkenstock checks all the boxes for best overall boot and are well priced for their quality. This lace up boot is not only stylish but also provides arch and ankle support. The insole is made of cork and is designed for stabilizing the foot with features like its deep heel cup, longitudinal and transverse arch supports. The upper is made from soft suede leather, which is comfortable and conforming to the shape of your foot.

For Flat Feet: People with flat feet are prone to experiencing pain along the arch as well as tendonitis pain if they do not wear shoe gear that is supportive. Pajar’s Galat boot comes with a removable comfort molded insole which is a perfect structural solution for a flat foot.  The insole serves as a supportive brace for the arch of the foot.

For High Arches: People with high arched feet are likely to experience ankle instability and can be prone to ankle sprains. The Fiona boot from La Canadienne provides inherent ankle stability via their lace up mechanism.  The ankle is further protected with the height of the boot extending to the calf.  The lug sole design is strong, yet lightweight and the sturdy, low heel and leather upper make this a go to boot for high arches.

The Best for Everyday: The Agatha boot by Mephisto is my top choice for best everyday wear. The upper is made of nubuck leather. This is a high-quality leather that will conform to the foot with wear; making them super comfortable. The outsole is made of rubber which aids in shock absorption with every step. They have a small, 2cm wedge heel that is designed for style and comfort. All these features make them ideal for effortless walking, and the top choice for best everyday wear.

The Best Non-Slip: Columbias Ice Maiden II combine style and technology into one winter weather ready boot. Its leather outsole has specially formulated treads and blends lug patterns and rubber for reliable grip on all terrain.

The Most Breathable: The nubuck calf skin leather of the Comley boot from Arche is ultra-high-quality material, and very breathable. They are built with a sturdy, 3.7cm heel and a sole made from natural rubber, Lactae Hévéa. The Lactae Hévéa sole is provides exceptional comfort to the foot through its unique alveolar microstructure made up of an infinite number of air bubbles. Although these boots come with a hefty price tag, they are an investment that will last you through the years.

For Wide Feet: Most shoes are problematic and painful for those with wide feet. To prevent frustration and discomfort from shoes that are too narrow, those with wide feet will benefit from specific brands that offer a “wide” option for width, like the Meyer boot from Franco Sarto. These riding style boots have a protective leather knee high shaft (that also is wide), sturdy toe box and low heel, designed to comfort a wider foot type.